The Hamas 'Peace' Gambit
by Charles Krauthammer
The Washington Post, May 8, 2009
The Times conducted a five-hour interview
with Hamas leader Khaled Mashaal at his Damascus headquarters. Mirabile
dictu, they're offering a peace plan with a two-state solution. Except.
The offer is not a peace but a truce that expires after 10 years. Meaning
that after Israel has fatally weakened itself by settling millions of
hostile Arab refugees in its midst, and after a decade of Hamas arming
itself within a Palestinian state that narrows Israel to eight miles wide
- Hamas restarts the war against a country it remains pledged to eradicate.
There is a phrase for such a peace: the peace of the grave.
Westerners may be stupid, but Hamas is not. It sees the
new American administration making overtures to Iran and Syria. It sees
Europe, led by Britain, beginning to accept Hizbullah. It sees itself
as next in line. And it knows what to do. Yasser Arafat wrote the playbook.
With the 1993 Oslo Accords, he showed what can be achieved
with a fake peace treaty with Israel - universal diplomatic recognition,
billions of dollars of aid and control of Gaza and the West Bank, which
Arafat turned into an armed camp. In return for a signature, he created
in the Palestinian territories the capacity to carry on the war against
Israel that the Arab states had begun in 1948 but had given up after the
bloody hell of the 1973 Yom Kippur War.
Mashaal sees the opportunity. Not only
is the Obama administration reaching out to its erstwhile enemies in the
region, but it begins its term by wagging an angry finger at Israel over
the Netanyahu government's ostensible refusal to accept a two-state solution.
Of all the phony fights to pick with Israel. No Israeli
government would turn down a two-state solution in which the Palestinians
accepted territorial compromise and genuine peace with a Jewish state.
(And any government that did would be voted out in a day.) Binyamin Netanyahu's
own defense minister, Ehud Barak, offered precisely such a deal in 2000.
He even offered to divide Jerusalem and expel every Jew from every settlement
remaining in the new Palestine.
The Palestinian response (for those who have forgotten)
was: No. And no counteroffer. Instead, nine weeks later, Arafat unleashed
a savage terror war that killed 1,000 Israelis.
Netanyahu is reluctant to agree to a Palestinian state before
he knows what kind of state it will be. That elementary prudence should
be shared by anyone who's been sentient the last three years. The Palestinians
already have a state, an independent territory with not an Israeli settler
or soldier living on it. It's called Gaza. And what is it? A terror base,
Islamist in nature, Iranian-allied, militant and aggressive, that has
fired more than 10,000 rockets and mortars at Israeli civilians.
If this is what a West Bank state is going
to be, it would be madness for Israel or America or Jordan or Egypt or
any other moderate Arab country to accept such a two-state solution. Which
is why Netanyahu insists that the Palestinian Authority first build institutions
- social, economic and military - to anchor a state that could actually
carry out its responsibilities to keep the peace.
Apart from being reasonable, Netanyahu's two-state skepticism
is beside the point. His predecessor, Ehud Olmert, worshiped at the shrine
of a two-state solution. He made endless offers of a two-state peace to
the Palestinian Authority - and got nowhere.
Why? Because the Palestinians— going back to the UN
partition resolution of 1947— have never accepted the idea of living
side by side with a Jewish state. Those like PA President Mahmoud Abbas,
who might want to entertain such a solution, have no authority to do it.
And those like Hamas's Mashaal, who have authority, have no intention
of ever doing it.
Mashaal's gambit to dress up perpetual war as a two-state
peace is yet another iteration of the Palestinian rejectionist tragedy.
In its previous incarnation, Arafat lulled Israel and the Clinton administration
with talk of peace while he methodically prepared his people for war.
Arafat waited seven years to tear up his
phony peace. Mashaal's innovation? Ten— then blood.
Facts and Logic About the Middle East
P.O. Box 590359
San Francisco, CA 94159
Gerardo Joffe, President
Return to top of page>>
|