The Fence
Will the Fence calm the region or exacerbate
the conflict?
After more than three years of the intifada, Israel
has decided to build a protective fence that would separate “Israel
proper” from the “West Bank” and protect its citizens
from murderous assaults which so far have caused over 1,000 Jewish deaths.
What are the facts?
A nation at war. Israel is at war—a war imposed on
it by its mortal enemies. The Arabs are prepared to do anything at all,
including their individual or collective self-immolation to attain their
murderous ends. During the last three years, during their so-called Al
Aksa intifada, scores of young Palestinians have blown themselves up in
order to take as many of the hated Jews as possible with them. They have
been most “successful” in that grisly endeavor.
Israel has refrained from inflicting serious punishment
on its tormentors. Clearly, Israel’s military might would enable
it to destroy its enemies quickly, but decency and respect for human life
keep it from that. Instead, Israel decided to build a protective Fence,
the course of which essentially follows the “green line,”
the armistice line from the 1948 War of Liberation. The only purpose of
the Fence is to keep suicide bombers out of “Israel proper”
and to seal it off from Judea/Samaria (the “West Bank”). The
Fence causes inconvenience and hardship for the Arabs. Before the intifada,
up to 200,000 of them went daily to their jobs in Israel. Now, that source
of income is cut off. More than 50 per cent of its employable men are
out of work and unable to feed their families.
The one person guilty of having brought this suffering,
this misery on his people is Yasser Arafat, the president of the so-called
“Palestinian Authority.” World opinion and even our own government
prevent Israel from touching this archvillain and from bringing him to
justice.
Some misconceptions. It is not clear why
so many are opposed to Israel’s protective Fence. The radical left
is protesting it in noisy rallies all over the world. Some call it a “wall,”
bringing up odious images of the wall erected by the Soviet Union to prevent
mass flights to the West. But the Israeli Fence is not that. Only less
than four miles out of the eighty-three miles that have been built so
far actually constitute a wall, rather than a fence. The walled portions
were built in areas where sniper incidents have occurred.
Another misconception about the Fence is that it intrudes
on “Palestinian land.” It is true that the Fence—the
portions that are now built and the portions that are still to be built—extends
in some localities across the “green line.” That is only in
order to include that small part of the “West Bank” in which
about 75 per cent of Israelis beyond the “green line” now
live. Some people are in uproar because they argue that Israel has de
facto annexed “Palestinian land.” But that is nonsense, of
course. There is no “Palestinian land.” It is only the constant
repetition that makes people believe that the “West Bank”
belongs to the “Palestinians.” Judea/Samaria (the “West
Bank”) is part of the Jewish homeland. Any land that Israel might
eventually yield to the Arabs to establish some kind of autonomy would
be an act of generosity and accommodation unprecedented in world history.
Israel has tremendous expenses for its educational and social
needs. No Israeli decision maker would waste money on a fence if the constant
atrocity attacks had not made it imperative. If attacks were to stop,
the Fence project could be immediately halted. Those who oppose the Fence
and refer to it as an “apartheid wall” either do not understand
the horror that suicide terrorists inflict on Israel’s civilian
population or they do not wish Israel well. But if the Arabs would abandon
their obsession to obliterate the Jewish state, and once they demonstrated
that they truly wished to live in peace with Israel and participate in
its prosperity and booming economy, the Fence could be torn down in no
time at all. But that happy day seems far away.
What is wrong with a fence? We have a 70-mile-long fence—ultimately
to be lengthened to 330 miles—snaking along the Mexican border.
Its purpose is not to keep murderous intruders at bay, but to prevent
people looking for work from entering our country. How can we then ask
the Israelis not to build a fence to protect the lives of their citizens?
The Gaza Strip is and has been for years surrounded by such a fence. Not
a single suicide attacker has ever been able to cross into Israel from
Gaza, while, with devastating “success,” hundreds have been
able to cross the open border of the “West Bank.” And then
there was the “good fence” between Lebanon and Israel, which
for many years Lebanese workers could daily cross into Israel and earn
their livelihood. The corollary of the wise saying that good fences make
good neighbors is that bad neighbors require good fences. And surely,
the Arab terrorists are the very worst neighbors that could happen to
Israel.
This ad has been published and paid for by
Facts and Logic About the Middle East
P.O. Box 590359
San Francisco, CA 94159
Gerardo Joffe, President
Return to top of page>>
|