|
|
Mubarak Awad
Was Israel justified in expelling him?
For the last few months, there have been almost
daily stories in the press and on television about Mubarak Awad, an American
citizen of Arab-Palestinian heritage. The Israeli government expelled
Awad and returned him to his adopted country the United States.
Our government has taken interest in the case and has expressed its concern
to Israel about this matter. It's easy to get confused.
What are the facts?
Awad's background. Mubarak Awad is an Arab, born
in the eastern sector of Jerusalem. Like all other Arabs resident in Jerusalem,
he was offered Israeli citizenship. He declined that and chose to remain
a Jordanian subject. In 1969, Awad immigrated to the United States. He
married an American citizen and became himself an American citizen by
naturalization. Israeli law stipulates that a non-citizen resident who
lives outside the area for seven years loses his resident status. Availing
himself of his U.S. citizenship, Awad started making periodic visits to
Israel. During his sojourns as a "tourist" and under the cover
of his U.S. citizenship, Awad organized the "Palestine Center for
the Study of Non-Violence." That organization promotes general civil
rebellion of the Arab population of Judea/Samaria (the "West Bank")
and Gaza. In his writings and exhortations, Awad describes such tactics
as "supplement to the 'armed struggle' for liberation." In the
Middle East setting, "armed struggle" is a notorious code word
for terrorism.
Having exhausted the forbearance of the Israeli authorities,
the government of Israel decided to expel him and to send him back to
the United States, of which he is a citizen. This, almost inexplicably,
produced much outcry and was cited by some as another example of Israeli
ruthlessness and disregard for human rights. But one basic attribute of
sovereignty is that a nation can determine which foreigners may or may
not reside in its country and to expel anybody whom they consider undesirable.
The U.S. routinely refuses entry into the country to those whose political
activities we think of as being contrary to our interests. Until recently,
we even barred those whose sexual orientation did not conform to the norm.
And we routinely expel those who are here illegally, who have overstayed
their visas, or who are engaged in activities that we consider contrary
to the interests of our country. In most cases, these matters are handled
summarily. Usually only in cases of American citizens, such as in the
case of the mass-murdered Demjanjuk, who was ultimately extradited to
Israel, does it take judicial action.
Abuse of rights. How then can the Israeli government
possibly be faulted for expelling Awad? He totally abused his rights as
a tourist, because the real purpose of his visits was to incite the Arab
population of Israel and of the administered territories to insurrection,
civil disobedience and "armed struggle." The Israelis would
have been quite within their rights not to allow him to enter the country
in the first place, or to expel him during the term of his visa. But they
allowed him to stay months after the expiration of his visa and expelled
him ultimately only after he emerged as one of the top leaders of the
current Arab uprising against Israeli authority. Even then, and in deference
to the United States, Awad has allowed to exhaust every judicial recourse
and, in a process that took months, carried his case to the Israeli Supreme
Court. That court, which, just as in the United States, is totally independent
of the government, unanimously decided that the expulsion was legal. Awad
was put on a plane and sent back to the U.S.
Why martyrdom for Awad? Those who are determined
to bestow the mantle of martyrdom on Mubarak Awad call him an "apostle
of non-violence" and compare him to Gandhi and Martin Luther King.
But the reality is quite different. Dr. King deeply loved America and
tried to strengthen it through his campaign of non-violence. By explicitly
supporting the terrorist PLO, by declaring violence to be a legitimate
means of advancing Palestinian political goals, by viewing non-violence
as a tactical complement to violence in the Palestinian uprising, and
by subscribing to the PLO's concept of "armed struggle" and
to the ultimate liquidation of Israel, he revealed himself as what he
really is: a revolutionary to whom "non-violence" is only one
of many revolutionary weapons.
Misuse of American citizenship. As Americans we must
be particularly concerned about Awad's misuse of his American citizenship.
In becoming an American citizen, he took an oath to forswear all foreign
allegiances and to reside permanently in the United States. He clearly
broke his oath on at least those two counts. Before the Israeli Supreme
Court, he declared that he had used his "American citizenship and
passport solely for bureaucratic reasons of convenience, without attaching
any importance and weight whatsoever," and that he "viewed Jerusalem
as his place of residence always."
He made statements to the same effect on the MacNeil/Lehrer
Report of Tuesday, June 14. Mubarak Awad treated the priceless gift of
American citizenship with disdain and cynically used it for his political
purposes and his foreign entanglements. How fortunate for Awad that we
Americans are such good-natured, forgiving and patient people! Any other
country would at the very least have stripped him of the citizenship that
he had acquired by swearing falsely and with the obligations of which
he never intended to comply.
It is clear that Israel was totally within its rights to
expel Mubarak Awad, a rabble-rouser who used the cover of his U.S. citizenship
and the protection of his U.S. passport to foment revolution in Israel
and in the territories administered by Israel. Israel would have been
fully justified in expelling him summarily. But they gave him every legal
opportunity to have the expulsion order rescinded. Awad's assumed role
as a latter-day Gandhi or Martin Luther King is a sham. Disregarding all
other aspects of this case, his true personality is revealed in his cynical
and cavalier misuse of his American citizenship.
This ad has been published and paid for by
Facts and Logic About the Middle East
P.O. Box 590359
San Francisco, CA 94159
Gerardo Joffe, President
Return to top of page>>
|