Israel's Borders
Are they "legitimate"? Should they
be changed?
Many in the Arab world insist that the State of
Israel is "illegitimate" and that, in order to be considered
for "recognition," it must, at the very least, "adjust"
its borders. In order to justify that insistent demand, Arab propaganda
has created many myths. By dint of constant repetition, some of these
myths have come to be accepted as reality.
What are some of these myths and what are the facts?
Myth: The establishment of the State of Israel in
1948 changed border arrangements that had existed for centuries.
Fact: The borders in the Middle East were drawn arbitrarily
after World War I by Britain and France. In the spoils, Britain got Iraq
and Palestine. In 1922, contrary to the Balfour Declaration and to its
Mandate from the League of Nations, Britain gave the area east of the
Jordan River (77% of Palestine) to the Hashemite tribes.
Myth: Israel has been expansionist since its establishment.
Fact: In 1974, Israel returned to Syria territories
captured in the 1967 and 1973 defensive wars. In exchange for a peace
treaty, Israel returned the vast Sinai area in Egypt, with flourishing
cities, strategic installations, and economic assets. Thus Israel proved
conclusively that peace and security -- not extra land are its
top priorities.
Myth: Judea and Samaria (also called "the West
Bank") are part of Jordan.
Fact: The British allocated the area east of the
Jordan River to the Hashemite tribes. These tribes founded a kingdom and
called it Transjordan. In 1948, after the declaration of Israel's independence,
the British-led Transjordanians attacked the newly founded Jewish state
and were able to occupy Judea/Samaria (the "West Bank") and
the eastern part of Jerusalem. They renamed themselves "Jordan"
and stayed in that occupation for 19 years, until they were defeated and
driven out by Israel in the 1967 Six Day War.
Myth: Israeli settlements in Judea/Samaria (the "West
Bank") are illegal, an obstacle in peace.
Fact: Contrary to what Arab propaganda suggests,
Jordan was never sovereign in Judea/Samaria (the "West Bank").
Thus, the constantly repeated accusation of "Israeli occupation"
is pointless. Numerous international legal authorities, among them Eugene
Rostow, have shown conclusively that Israel's rights in Judea/Samaria
(the "West Bank") are based on international law and are further
affirmed by U.N. Resolutions 242 and 338. President Reagan concluded that
Jewish settlements are not illegal and that "...all people
Moslems, Jews, and Christians are entitled to live in the West
Bank."
Myth: Israel annexed the Golan Heights illegally
and has no right to hold onto them.
Fact: The Golan Heights is a desolate area, far smaller
than Long Island, NY. The arbitrary boundary lines drawn after World War
I did place the Golan Heights in Syria. It put Israel at an impossible
military disadvantage. From 1948 until Israel captured the Heights in
the 1967 Six Day War, Syria subjected Israeli settlements in the plains
below to constant bombardment. Israel has always been prepared to negotiate
all issues with Syria, including the status of the Golan Heights.
Myth: Israel's insistence on defensible borders is
unrealistic in this age of missiles and long-range bombers.
Fact: Israel, including Judea/Samaria (the "West
Bank") has an area about half the size of San Bernardino County in
California. In contrast, the land area of the Arab nations is twice that
of the U.S. If Israel were to give up Judea/Samaria, it would only be
nine miles (!) wide between the Arab military machine and the Mediterranean
Sea. That narrow waist contains 75% of Israel's population and most of
its industrial installations. Missile and bombers would not be needed.
In case of attack, Israel could not mobilize and its principal population
centers would be reduced to rubble within a matter of minutes.
Israel is the only victorious country in recorded history
that has surrendered vast territories to the vanquished. Still, Israel
is not prepared to commit suicide by yielding to propaganda and myth and
by adjusting its boundaries to suit the purposes of its implacable enemies.
The insistence on "adjustment" of borders is one step in the
plan for its destruction. One hundred retired U.S. generals and admirals
and the Joint Chiefs of Staff are agreed that Israel must retain the Jordan
River as its border in order to be defensible. The solution? Sit down
at the negotiating table and work out an agreement on borders, just as
Israel did with Egypt. Israel has been ready for such talks for over twenty
years. So far, only Egypt has finally agreed to sit down and talk to Israel.
All other countries concerned consider themselves in a state of war with
Israel, deny its "existence" and will not consider any talks
or negotiations..
This ad has been published and paid for by
Facts and Logic About the Middle East
P.O. Box 590359
San Francisco, CA 94159
Gerardo Joffe, President
Return to top of page>>
|