You are receiving this email because you have requested news, facts and analysis about Israel and the Mideast conflict. If you DO NOT want to continue receiving free messages like the one below, go here.
August 10, 2004
Friend of FLAME:
When was the last time you were forced to go through a metal detector
or had your purse or briefcase opened and examined? How did you feel
about these security measures? Inconvenienced? Frustrated at your loss
of time? How about humiliated? (Frankly, I'm usually just a bit relieved
that someone at the airport cares enough to protect us from terrorism.)
Yet one hears a great deal about the "humiliation" that Arabs
feel when they're made to undergo security procedures---in Iraq and
in Israel's disputed territories. This excellent article by Eli Hertz,
which appeared in Jewish World, takes a hard look at the question of
humiliation in Israel and the territories---and why it's a red herring.
It is not Israel or the West who are humiliating people, whether they
be Arabs, Israelis or Westerners. It is terrorists. Let's place the
blame for humiliation where it belongs.
Who is Humiliating Whom?
by Eli E. Hertz
July 25, 2004, Jewish World (a publication of www.aish.org)
The average Israeli is "humiliated and harassed" by being
searched far more times a day than the average Palestinian.
Palestinians say they feel humiliated and harassed when Israeli authorities
search them and their belongings; when they are prevented from traveling
freely because of checkpoints, roadblocks, closures and curfews. They
say they feel "corralled" behind security fences and ugly
Israel is criticized for these measures even by those who understand
the causal relationship that makes such security steps necessary. The
cynical use of the movement of innocent Palestinians, including people
in need of urgent medical treatment(1) and Palestinian day laborers
crossing to work in Israel is used as a convenient cover for the perpetration
of terrorist acts.
Palestinians take advantage of Israel's sensitivity to Arab female honor
to mobilize women as live bombs. The two latest -- a 40-year-old mother
of seven who carried a suicide belt across army checkpoints; and the
second, Reem Salah Riashi, 21, a mother of two young children who dreamed
of "becoming a martyr" since she was 13.
Riashi, approaching a checkpoint, claimed a medical disability; she
said she had a metal pin in her leg and was escorted to an examination
room to be checked by a female security officer. She then blew herself
up, murdering four Israelis and wounding 12. As a result, Palestinian
women and patients who appear to be in obvious pain will no longer be
exempt from thorough physical scrutiny, to ensure that they, too, are
not human bombs.
This increased hardship for innocent Palestinians has been caused by
their own leadership, which cynically continues to claim that the Israelis
humiliate their citizens.
Strangely, no media outlets and not a single human rights organization
has fully and objectively reported or protested the daily humiliation
and harassment Israelis suffer because of the Palestinian Authority's
'factory of terror.'
In Israel, every Israeli is searched numerous times during the course
of a day. Israelis are asked to open their bags and purses for inspection.
In most cases, they are subjected to body searches with a metal detector
every time they enter a bank or a post office, pick up a bottle of milk
at the supermarket, enter a mall or train station, or visit a hospital
or medical clinic. Young Israeli men and women are physically frisked
in search of suicide belts before they enter crowded nightclubs.
As a matter of routine, Israelis' car trunks are searched every time
they enter a well-trafficked parking lot. Daily, their cars pass through
roadblocks that cause massive traffic jams when security forces are
in hot pursuit of suicide bombers believed to have entered Israel. Far
from a rare occasion, in the two and a half months of relative quiet
between the October 4, 2003 bombing of the Maxsim Restaurant, a popular
Christian-Jewish-owned eatery in Haifa (which left 22 dead and more
than a 100 injured) and Christmas, a Christian day of peace, 24 suicide
bombers headed for Israel proper and another 15 with West Bank targets
were apprehended before they could reach their destinations.
Israelis are searched not only when they go out for a cup of coffee
at the local Starbucks or Pizza Hut, but also when they go to the movies
or the theater or a concert, where the term "dressed to kill"
has an entirely different meaning.
These ordinary daily humiliations now extend to similar searches when
Israelis go to weddings or bar mitzvahs. No one abroad talks about the
humiliation Jews in Israel are subjected to, having to write at the
bottom of wedding invitations and other life cycle events, "The
site will be secured [by armed guards]" -- to ensure relatives
and friends will attend and share their joyous occasion.
One out of four Israeli children, ages 11 to 15, fear for their lives.
One out of three report they fear for the lives of their family members,
and more than a third report they have changed their patterns of travel
and social lives due to security concerns. (2)
These ubiquitous security checks do not exist in Arab cities and towns
in Israel (or, for that matter, in the West Bank and Gaza) because those
places are not and never have been targets of Palestinian terrorism.
In fact, the average Israeli is "humiliated and harassed"
by being searched far more times a day than the average Palestinian.
Not one human rights group has so much as noted this massive intrusion
into the rights of privacy and person imposed on Israelis.
The latest source of criticism is the security fence -- designed to
serve as a barrier against Palestinian suicide bombers, a measure critics
brand as a form of ghettoization and another form of Israeli harassment.
To date, no one protests the fact that, since the 1970s, Jewish schoolchildren
in Israel are surrounded by perimeter fences, with armed guards at the
schoolyard gates, as if their schools were the domiciles of Mafiosi.
Not one Arab village in Israel or the Territories has a perimeter fence
around it. Guards are not required at Arabic shops, cafes, restaurants,
movie theaters, wedding halls or schools -- either in Israel or in the
Territories. Palestinians also do not need armed guards to accompany
every school trip, youth movement hike or campout. They are not targets
Arab children have never been willfully attacked by Jews, while Arabs
have purposefully murdered Jewish youngsters at boarding schools, junior
high school students on overnight trips and teens on a nature hike.
Arab Palestinians attacked Jewish school buses carrying elementary school
children (twice), murdered two children playing in a cave near their
homes, killed a toddler in a nursery and murdered small children hiding
under their beds -- all in addition to wave after wave of suicide bombings.
Countless Israelis in sensitive areas within the Green Line -- not only
in the Territories, but also in Jewish towns, villages and bedroom suburbs
-- are "ghettoized" behind high fences. Three years ago, Jewish
urbanites in the Gilo neighborhood of Jerusalem were closed in by an
ugly high concrete wall that blocked their view of the city and the
bullets of Palestinian gunmen from the Arab neighborhood of Beit Jallah.
While the General Assembly protests the inconvenience Palestinians suffer
because of the layout of the security fence, not one UN organ has protested
the fact that, for years, an entire country has been harassed and humiliated.
Israelis traveling north from Jerusalem to the Beit She'an Valley, or
south from Jerusalem to Beersheba, have been forced to make a 60 to
90-minute detour to avoid traveling across the West Bank and the Jordan
Valley, where drive-by shootings by Palestinian snipers and other attacks
on civilian traffic threaten their lives.
Motorists traveling between Jerusalem and Tel Aviv on Route 443 are
forced to negotiate a lengthy trough-like gauntlet that runs between
two high concrete walls that protect them from Palestinian sniper fire.
Yet there have been no UN protests against these walls -- only against
the 'ugly' wall that prevents terrorists from the Palestinian town of
Qalqiliya, (3) from attacking cars "inside Israel" on a major
cross-country toll road, and against a number of other short sections,
where the security barrier is concrete, not fencing.
Israelis' freedom of movement is compromised daily as countless citizens
seek to avoid crowded areas or events, change their daily routines by
sticking to side streets, avoid traveling close to public buses, or
simply stay out of the heart of their own capital entirely. Most school
trips have been cancelled or curtailed during the past three years.
Many Israeli motorists avoid major arteries that pass through Arab areas
of Israel, while Arab citizens and Palestinians from the Territories
continue to enter Jewish cities and go about their business without
peril. Israelis are told, in effect, to disguise themselves when traveling
abroad - not to speak Hebrew in public and not to wear garments that
reveal their Jewish/Israeli origins. Even Israel's national airline
-- El Al -- has been forced to remove its logo from the tails of its
aircraft at certain airports, out of concern for the safety of its passengers.
This followed several attempts to down Israeli civilian aircraft with
missiles. On the other hand, Arabs who frequent Jewish cities and towns
in Israel wear their traditional Arab headgear without fear of being
attacked or harassed.
An article in Forbes, "Cold Calculation of Terror," estimates
Israeli economic losses due to continuous terrorism is 3 percent of
the $110 billion gross domestic product. Tourism alone fell 50 percent
and lost $2 billion [yearly].
As of this writing, "Interrogation of terrorists belonging to various
organizations in Samaria has indicated that the security barrier does
indeed present a significant obstacle to terrorists wishing to infiltrate
into Israeli territory." (4) The security fence, in areas where
already constructed, is remarkably effective and saves lives.
Can the UN General Assembly calculate the 'proportionality' of building
a fence that saves lives to Palestinian terrorism and barbarism?
All this begs the question: Who are the victims and who are the victimizers?
Who are the ones being harassed and humiliated? Palestinians or Israelis?
(1) Such dastardly conduct extends to hiding suicide belts under sick
children in ambulances, using ambulances to move operatives in and out
of closed areas disguised as paramedics or patients in need of immediate
care - then complaining that heartless Israelis stop ambulances.
(2) "Survey: 1 in 4 teens live in fear of terror," Jerusalem
Post, June 3, 2004. See at http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?pagename=JPost/JPArticle/ShowFull&cid=1086230744079
(3) What the Secretary-General report does not disclose is the fact
that Qalqiliya was and is a home to Palestinian terrorists who produced
so far five terror attacks on civilian targets within Israel, contributing
to the death of 28 innocent civilians and many more injuries. The last
non-lethal incident took place on August 31, 2003, when an Israeli Arab
construction worker was moderately wounded in a shooting attack. See
(4) Intelligence and Terrorism Information Center at the Center for
Special Studies (C.S.S) at http://www.intelligence.org.il/