make a donation

Why Donate to FLAME?

By supporting FLAME, you help fund our ads in national media, like U.S. News and World Report, The New York Times, The Nation, The National Review, The American Spectator, The Washington Times National Weekly, and others. You help publish our messages in Jewish publications, both in the U.S. and in Israel, among them The International Edition of the Jerusalem Post. Finally, your donation helps us publish our messages monthly in over fifty small-town newspapers, all across the United States and Canada.


Facts and Logic About
the Middle East
P.O. Box 590359
San Francisco, CA 94159
(415) 356-7801

April 18, 2007

When the Arabs Blame Israel for Their Problems, They Ignore A World of Self-Inflicted Failure

Dear Friend of FLAME:

David Brooks’ recent New York Times opinion piece, “A war of narratives,” reprinted below, really hits the nail on the head.  In the prevailing Arab “narrative,” all the problems in the Arab world are due to Israel.  In the Arab world, where Osama bin Laden is the Arabs’ most adulated hero because he committed the 9/11 deed (though everyone in that world also knows that “Israel’s Mossad was responsible for 9/11”), the crazy logic that “Israel is the cause of all Arab misfortunes” does indeed make sense.

However, in our world, a world that strives for rational analysis by means of objectivity and the evaluation of all relevant facts, things look different.

In the real world, Israel cannot be blamed for:

  • The Muslim enslavement of black Africans in Mauritania,
  • The mass murder of hundreds of thousands of Arabs in a 13-year Algerian civil war,
  • The endless brutal oppression of Egyptian Christian Copts in Egypt by Egyptian Muslims,
  • The genocide of 2,000,000 black African Christians and animists in South Sudan by Sudanese Muslim Arabs over the past 23 years,
  • The genocide of 800,000 black African Muslims in Western Sudan (aka Darfur) by Sudanese Muslim Arabs over the past 5 years,
  • The blatant religious apartheid of the Saudi government in Arabia,
  • The mass murder of Arabian Shi’ites by the Saudi royal family,
  • The de facto maintenance of slavery as an economic institution in Arabia,
  • Saddam Hussein’s murder of hundreds of thousands of his own Iraqi citizens during his 32 years of repressive tyrannical rule,
  • The current Muslim-vs.-Muslim terrorist carnage in Iraq,
  • The Taliban reign of terror in Afghanistan,
  • The decades-old civil war between Islamofascists and non-Muslims in Nigeria,
  • Syria’s brutal 27-year occupation of Lebanon,
  • Six decades of Muslim terrorism against the Hindus of Kashmir and Gujarat,
  • The Muslim repression of Hindus in Bangladesh,
  • Islamic terrorism in East Asia (Bali, East Timor, Philippines, Malaysia, Indonesia),
  • Muslim terrorism against Russia (remember 186 dead children at the school in Beslan?)
  • The brutal Islamic subjugation of women prevalent in many Muslim countries for the last millennium,
  • The Muslim persecution of Christians and Jews throughout the Muslim world since the beginning of Islam,
  • The fact that the “religion of peace” spawned a thousand-year war against the non-Muslim world (aka Jihad) a thousand years before Israel came in to existence,
  • The grinding poverty and lack of productivity that typify even the richest of Arab countries, as documented in three recent UN-sponsored studies,
  • The fact that, while not all Muslims are terrorists, almost all terrorists, for the past 30 years, are Muslims,
  • The fact that millions of Muslims every year flee their home states, Shari’a law, and Islamic sovereignty, to seek refuge, a better life, broader opportunities, freedom and a brighter future for their children . . . in Western states.

The appalling Arab narrative that Brooks summarizes below reflects a steadfast denial of reality, rooted concretely and unshakably in the Arab concepts of ash-Sharaf (male honor) and al-Haram (shame).  To accept blame for failure causes loss of face, shame, loss of honor.  So the political and religious and intellectual leadership of the Arab world descend to the irrational fantasy of what Brooks correctly calls the “Zionist-centric mythology,” in order to supply a face-saving scapegoat for their own failures.

Until Arab leaders are willing to accept responsibility for their own cultural dysfunctionality, they and their unfortunate subjects are unlikely to emerge from social, economic and political bankruptcy.  Obviously, blaming Israel does not merely miss the point, it also creates a profoundly dangerous misrepresentation of the root cause of the conflict.  It confuses the arsonist (obdurate Arab hatred of Jews) with the fire-fighter (Israel defending itself against Arab terrorism).  Given this intransigent Arab hatred of Jews and Israel---as well as the message of misappropriated blame---it is not just folly for the USA to pressure Israel to make concessions when negotiating Middle East peace deals; it is actually a mechanism that stokes violence by supporting the Arab lie, and it weakens Israel’s ability to defend itself.

It’s time that Western governments stop pretending to believe the Arab lie.  It’s time to address the real root causes of the relentless Arab war against Israel and the Jews.

David Meir-Levi
Contributing Editor, FLAME



Despite the unremitting hostility of Arab and other Muslim leaders [like the scathing anti-American invectives issued several weeks ago by our “friend” King Abdullah of Saudi Arabia], many pundits and politicians still try to push the U.S. and Israel into appeasement.  If you believe it’s critical to continue to expose Arab and Muslim duplicity, I hope you’ll choose to support FLAME.  Our hasbarah [clarifying messages] appear in mass media like U.S. News & World Report, The New Republic and American Spectator, and reach more than 5 million homes every month.  A great example is our most recent message, which speaks precisely to this week’s Hotline topic: “The ‘Root Cause’ of the Middle East Turmoil: Would peace descend if the Arab-Israeli conflict were resolved?”  I urge you to review it and pass it along to friends and colleagues. (See it at Remember: All FLAME’s support comes from individuals like you, one by one. Can you help us now---with $500, $250, $100, or even $18? (Remember, your donation to FLAME is tax deductible.) Together we’re keeping the flame alive.  To donate online, just go to  Thanks for your continued support.

A War of Narratives
By David Brooks, New York Times, April 8, 2007

On the Dead Sea, Jordan

I just attended a conference that was both illuminating and depressing. It was co-sponsored by the Center for Strategic Studies at the University of Jordan and the American Enterprise Institute, and the idea was to get Americans and moderate Arab reformers together to talk about Iraq, Iran, and any remaining prospects for democracy in the Middle East.

As it happened, though, the Arab speakers mainly wanted to talk about the Israel lobby. One described a book edited in the mid-1990s by the Jewish policy analyst David Wurmser as the secret blueprint for American foreign policy over the past decade. A pollster showed that large majorities in Arab countries believe that the Israel lobby has more influence over American policy than the Bush administration. Speaker after speaker triumphantly cited the work of Stephen Walt, John Mearsheimer and Jimmy Carter as proof that even Americans were coming to admit that the Israel lobby controls their government.

The problems between America and the Arab world have nothing to do with religious fundamentalism or ideological extremism, several Arab speakers argued. They have to do with American policies toward Israel, and the forces controlling those policies.

As for problems in the Middle East itself, these speakers added, they have a common source, Israel. One elderly statesman noted that the four most pressing issues in the Middle East are the Arab-Israeli dispute, instability in Lebanon, chaos in Iraq and the confrontation with Iran. They are all interconnected, he said, and Israel is at the root of each of them.

We Americans tried to press our Arab friends to talk more about the Sunni-Shiite split, the Iraqi civil war and the rise of Iran, but they seemed uninterested. They mimicked a speech King Abdullah of Jordan recently delivered before Congress, in which he scarcely mentioned the Iraqi chaos on his border. It was all Israel, all the time.

The Americans, needless to say, had a different narrative. We tended to argue that problems like Muslim fundamentalism, extremism and autocracy could not be blamed on Israel or Paul Wolfowitz but had deeper historical roots. We tended to see the Israeli-Palestinian issue not as the root of all fundamentalism, but as a problem made intractable by fundamentalism.

In other words, they had their narrative and we had ours, and the two passed each other without touching. But the striking thing about this meeting was the emotional tone. There seemed to be a time, after 9/11, when it was generally accepted that terror and extremism were symptoms of a deeper Arab malaise. There seemed to be a general recognition that the Arab world had fallen behind, and that it needed economic, political and religious modernization.

But there was nothing defensive or introspective about the Arab speakers here. In response to Bernard Lewis’s question, “What Went Wrong?” their answer seemed to be: Nothing’s wrong with us. What’s wrong with you?

The events of the past three years have shifted their diagnosis of where the cancer is — from dysfunction in the Arab world to malevolence in Jerusalem and in Aipac. Furthermore, the Walt and Mearsheimer paper on the Israel lobby has had a profound effect on Arab elites. It has encouraged them not to be introspective, not to think about their own problems, but to blame everything on the villainous Israeli network.

And so we enter a more intractable phase in the conflict, which will not be a war over land or oil or even democratic institutions, but a war over narratives. The Arabs will nurture this Zionist-centric mythology, which is as self-flattering as it is self-destructive. They will demand that the U.S. and Israel adopt their narrative and admit historical guilt. Failing politically, militarily and economically, they will fight a battle for moral superiority, the kind of battle that does not allow for compromises or truces.

Americans, meanwhile, will simply want to get out. After 9/11, George Bush called on the U.S. to get deeply involved in the Middle East. But now, most Americans have given up on their ability to transform the Middle East and on Arab willingness to change. Faced with an arc of conspiracy-mongering, most Americans will get sick of the whole cesspool, and will support any energy policy or anything else that will enable them to cut ties with the region.

What we have is not a clash of civilizations, but a gap between civilizations, increasingly without common narratives, common goals or means of communication.

If you'd like a printer-friendly, text version of this newsletter click the button below.

How many times have you heard someone lament that Israel doesn't have good public relations? By supporting FLAME, you help one of the world's most powerful information efforts to spread the truth about Israel and the Middle East conflict. Please note that because FLAME is a non-profit 501(c)(3) corporation, your donation is tax-deductible.

If you know of a friend or colleague who would appreciate learning more Facts and Logic About the Middle East, please forward this issue of the FLAME HOTLINE to them using the link below.

If you have received this issue of the FLAME HOTLINE from a friend or colleague and you'd like to subscribe, please use the link below.

Our Ads and Positions | Donate | Our Letters to Editors | Our Acquisition Letters
FLAME's Purpose | Subscribe to Hotline Alerts | Home

©2004 FLAME. All rights reserved. | Site Credits | Contact Us

You are receiving this email because you have requested news, facts and analysis about Israel and the Mideast conflict. If you DO NOT want to continue receiving free messages like the one below, go here.